Hybrid Ring/Radial Final Circuits: Are They Acceptable?

Hybrid Ring/Radial Final Circuits: Are They Acceptable?
Photo Credit To Elecsa

The experts at ELECSA share their technical advice.

The NICEIC helpline is occasionally asked whether a ring final circuit has to be supplied directly from a protective device in the distribution board or consumer unit, or whether it is permitted to supply the two ends of the ring via a dedicated radial circuit cable, as shown in Fig 1, thereby forming a hybrid ring/radial circuit.

This situation can arise where, for example, the contractor wishes to make use of a redundant radial circuit cable previously installed for another purpose (such as a cooker circuit) to supply a ring final circuit, or where an Electrical Installation Condition Report (EICR) of an existing installation reveals such an arrangement.

The same query may also arise where a client wishes to control a ring final circuit by means of a switch for functional purposes, or possibly by means of an App controlled smart device for home automation. The supply is brought to the junction box, switch or smart device via a dedicated radial circuit cable.

It is permissible to form a hybrid ring/radial circuit, even though BS 7671 defines a ring final circuit as: ‘A final circuit arranged in the form of a ring and connected to a single point of supply’.

For such a hybrid circuit, the ‘single point of supply’ is the point at which the two ends of the ring part of the circuit are connected to the radial part (that is, at the joint box, switch or smart device in the example in shown in Fig 1).

A hybrid ring/radial final circuit must be arranged to meet all the relevant requirements of BS 7671, the main ones of which are summarised below.

Protection against electric shock

As for any other final circuit, the requirements of Chapter 41 for electric shock protection have to be met, including those of Section 411 for earth fault loop impedance (Zs) and, where applicable, RCD additional protection of the socket-outlets (I∆n ≤ 30 mA) in accordance with Regulation 411.3.3.

Furthermore, if any part of the circuit cable is concealed in a wall or partition, it must be provided with additional protection by an RCD (I∆n ≤ 30 mA) where required by Regulations 522.6.202 or 522.6.204.

Cable sizing with regard to normal load and overload

The current-carrying capacity (IZ) of the cable in the radial part of the circuit must be not less than 30 A or 32 A, to match the circuit overcurrent protective device rating (In) of 30 A or 32 A.

Where the protective device is a semienclosed (rewireable) fuse, IZ must be not less than In divided by 0.725. Regulation 433.1.202 refers.

The ring part of the circuit must meet the same overload protection requirements as for any other ring final circuit. The usual way to comply with these requirements is to comply with Regulation 433.1.204.

Despite the non-conventional form of a hybrid ring/radial circuit, the total load current (Ib) to be supplied by the circuit, making due allowance for any diversity, must still be no greater than the 30 A or 32 A rating of the circuit protective device. Thus, for example, the floor area served by the circuit should be no greater than would be the case if an ordinary ring final circuit having the same protective device rating was installed instead of the hybrid circuit.

Accessibility of connections

As is required for all electrical connections, the connections between the radial and ring parts of the circuit (in the junction box, switch or smart device in Fig 1) must be arranged to be accessible throughout the life of the installation for inspection, testing and maintenance. The only exception is where a connection method excused from this requirement by Regulation 526.3 is used.

Protective conductor in the ring part of the circuit

Except where the circuit protective conductor in the ring part of the circuit is formed by a metal covering (such as a metallic cable sheath) or enclosure (such as metal conduit) containing all the conductors of the ring, the protective conductor must be run in the form of a ring, as required by Regulation 543.2.9. Both ends of the protective conductor ring must be connected to the earthing terminal at the origin of the ring (that is, the junction box, switch or smart device in the figure shown).

Earthing for equipment having high protective conductor currents

If the circuit is intended to supply one or more items of equipment where it is known or reasonably to be expected that the total protective conductor current is likely to exceed 10 mA, the circuit will require a high integrity protective conductor connection in accordance with Regulation Group 543.7.

In the radial part of the circuit this will necessitate the use of a 10 mm2 circuit protective conductor in accordance with Regulation 543.7.1.203 (i), or one of the three arrangements (a), (b) and (c) listed in Regulation 543.7.2.201 (ii), for example.

Use of a standard circuit might be easier

It will be appreciated from this article that the use of a hybrid ring/radial circuit arrangement can involve significant design effort.

As an alternative, for household and similar installations, installers should consider the use of the standard ring or radial socket-outlet circuit arrangements shown in Appendix 15 of BS 7671.

For more information please visit www.elecsa.co.uk

Related posts